I recently had to decide whether to share the background and meaning of a piece of artwork. And to compound the process, the piece was for a family member. There is a belief that since art is a form of expression, the artist should take every opportunity to share the development and meaning of each piece.
“As artists we are visual communicators, so in that sense, it seems to me we have a responsibility to our audience that they understand, as much as possible, what we’re trying to communicate. Otherwise don’t bother showing the work to others. That’s not a popular opinion in this age of believing that the process of creating is more important than the result. I have difficulty with that belief; it has a tinge of selfishness to it that I don’t care for. …I believe everything that exists, visible or invisible, perceived or not, began with an idea, was created intentionally, and is designed to serve a purpose. All the luxuries and conveniences we so enjoy today are examples of that. I really don’t see objects that we create as being any different.” (John Potoschnik)
I have difficulty with this view. For example, I think we have all had the experience of connecting to a song. Maybe it’s simply an enjoyable rhythm or maybe the lyrics speak to something happening in our lives; whatever the reason, we crank up the volume every time we hear it. And then, one day we learn the background of the song or what the musician intended by those lyrics, and that knowledge becomes the wet fingers to the flame the song used to ignite.
I know, the opposite can also be true. After reading or hearing an interview with some of my favorite musicians, I become even more moved by their music. My point is, as an artist, it can be a risk to share too much. We are already being vulnerable by putting our work out there. I don’t want to potentially negatively influence someone else’s connection with a piece. And selfish or not, I don’t just make art for others, but for myself too.
Some pieces are inspired by deep emotions or times of healing or subconscious shit that needs to come out. Other pieces may be a well-executed exercise in technique or a relaxing reprieve between more complex and intense projects or just a very pleasing composition. And I’m not sure any of this SHOULD matter to the viewer. As the viewer, your connection is YOURS, regardless of the creator’s intent. As the viewer, you also take the risk of having that connection enhanced, altered, or diminished when you ask the artist for the background, intent, or meaning.
In my case, deciding to share SOME of the background to the piece purchased for my nephew, turned out to be the right call. I was incredibly nervous until he confirmed he understood because his connection was similar. Whew! I think for me, my rule is that I don’t share unless I’m asked, and even then, I may be careful with the details.
What are your thoughts? As an artist? As a viewer? What is your experience? I’ll contradict myself in asking: please share!
